Open Learning… exploring students’ fears about publishing on line
Posted by: cwmitchell in UncategorizedI have come across a surprising reservation amongst students towards one aspect of blog learning – the fact that it is public! Generally I am finding the whole experience of blog learning refreshing, engaging, even exciting. Students are having to take more personal responsibility for their learning and independence is emerging. The students are also less dependent on the teacher spoon-feeding them curriculum content. It is requiring more work from me but it is taking the emphasis off teacher and students and putting it more onto us all as learners.
However a problem I was not expecting was the resistance among some students to publish online. Young people are so fluent in online publishing (I have yet to meet a teenager who doesn’t have a MySpace page, a facebook account or a Photobucket or Bebo profile – most have them all) and they leave comments for each other daily and publish photos of themselves and their friends. Some of these accounts may be private but often the ‘friends’ are well over 100 people so this form of creative communication is very public. So why the fear about writing a blog post? What is clear is that young people see a difference between there social learning and opinion sharing and their study notes and course work. Some students have told me that they don’t want to be copied! Others have said that they are embarassed that people might read their work and think that they are wrong or even wors – stupid!
Both these points concern me for a number of reasons. Firstly has mainstream education conditioned these youngsters to actually believe in right and wrong opinions? Have we privatised learning so that we are scared to be original? Do we thing good ideas are something to be hidden and defended like gollum with his ring of power… Knowledge, wisdom and ideas kept to yourself are pointless and possibly poisenous. Have we made everything so transactional that good ideas are to be protected and only cashed in to get you the best grade rather than benefit anyone else’s thoughts? Where do we think the good ideas come from in the first place – if a young person puts a great point into their essay, do they really own it? Normally they understood what their teacher told them and I heard it from someone else or got it from a book and that book got it from somewhere else… Our cleverness is the mixing up of other people contributions - surely sharing ideas IS learning. Being wrong is really important and needs to become fun so that people take the risk and don’t hide their ideas and in so doing limit their learning potential.
Please do publish comments in response to this so we can all learn and decide our response to the fear, embarrassment or resistance to learn openly and publish online.
Here is a video clip from David Gauntlett – it may start of sounding a bit ‘clever’ or even ‘boring’ but listen to him and give it time – try to understand it, he says some really interesting stuff about moving from a ’sit back and be told’ way of learning to a ‘making and doing’ way of learning. This is what we are going for.
Comments welcome…






Entries (RSS)